Dissertation Proposals
1. Start writing rather than wait too long and risk paralysis.
2. It does not have to be perfect, circulate it early on to help refine your ideas and get feedback. 3.
Remember that the proposal is just a proposal-- a fantasy document, an
ideal—be aware that the project will
evolve. 4. Think of the proposal as an opportunity to organize your confusion. 5. Look at other proposals in your discipline – look at several because they vary in format 6.
Be aware of disciplinary expectations. For example, some
disciplines require general chapter descriptions while
others do not.
Abstracts for conferences, fellowships, etc.
1. Great way of experimenting with ideas for dissertation chapters 2.
Opportunity to hone research questions into brief simple statements
that can be understood by scholars outside
your area of specialty. 3. They are a good exercise in learning to state your ideas up front. 4. Take them as an opportunity to benefit from sharing your ideas with established scholars. 5.
When using jargon/specialized terminology be sure to clearly
state what you mena. Its purpose is to advance
your argument not to obscure
it! 6. Abstracts can be a good exercise in learning to express your project succinctly.
Working successfully with Advisors
1.
Think about the process strategically. There are advantages and
disadvantages to having junior v. senior faculty
as primary advisors. Generally, more
established scholars will have the experience to guide you and your
committee better. Keep in mind, senior faculty also tend to have larger
professional networks that you can
access. 2.
Think carefully about who your committee members are and what position
they are commenting from. Take
their feedback in stride 3. Be professionally pragmatic in your choice – but choose people who have time for you. 4. Filter their comments, and remember ultimately this is your project 5. This process is about developing your own professional and intellectual identity. 6. Don’t rely too much on advisors to go forward. Set your own deadlines.
Organizing Panels for Conferences
1.
Think beyond topical commonality. Look for unexpected linkages
that will produce fruitful conversations. 2. Cross disciplinarity is essential. 3.
Think carefully about how you name panels, they should not be too
narrow or too broad. Ask yourself what will
appeal to potential conference attendees. 4.
Conferences are good spaces to present ideas that are in different
phases of development—but the tradeoff is it
can be a drain on your time.
Conference papers and presentations
1. Take a conversational approach to presentations but be aware of disciplinary expectations. 2. Begin by telling your audience what to expect and then present your argument. 3. Don’t spend too much time on a lit review when presenting, focus on your ideas and conclusions. 4. Don’t over compensate by referencing everything you’ve ever done or read. 5.
Time and practice your presentation…running over the set time limit is
never a good way to present your work. 6. You
can use conference presentations to establish your expertise in a
particular area however, think through the
timing of presenting
your work publicly – you don’t want to give away your argument too soon. 7. Conferences can provide useful deadlines for getting ideas into written form.
Producing Dissertation Chapters
1. Set guidelines with your advisor about the process of creating and circulating drafts of your work. 2. Create peer dissertation groups – CRE work sessions are a good example 3.
Find appropriate venues to share your work – you need trustworthy
people to comment on your work, it should
be a place where you build confidence and get
constructive feedback. 4. Use regular meetings as deadlines for getting a chapter ready to circulate to appropriate peer group. 5.
It can be useful to circulate the first 5-10 pages of a chapter -
to see if it produces a good conversation about
what your chapter is
about. 6. You can circulate to different members of your committee at different points. 7.
Set deadlines –figure out a work schedule that works for you. Be
realistic about the deadlines you set and honor
them. 8. Though you
may not know it…you already know how to write a chapter! Think of
each chapter as an extended
seminar paper. The only difference your chapter has a
relationship to a larger framework.
Applying for Grants
1.
Apply often but be aware that rejection is part of the process.
Remember, there are things to be gained from the
application process itself. 2. Start preparing early. 3. Understand what the funder wants and gear your application to those wants. 4.
Explore different aspects of your project in funding applications –they
are a good way to determine how flexible
the boundaries of your project are. 5.
Know the audience that you are writing to – it may be useful to talk to
faculty or other students who have
applied. 6.
Readers are not necessarily knowledgeable about your specialty or
topic. Make it compelling to a general
academic
audience. 7. Informal or formal discussion
groups are a great resource for circulating, revising and strategizing
for funding
applications. For example, work
sessions at the CRE are a great environment for this purpose.
Writing Challenges
1. Just do it. Don’t get stranded in preparation. Write everyday. 2. Find your own rhythm – what time of day you work best – and once you find that time, protect it zealously. 3.
You will tempted to procrastinate, fight the urge when you can.
Figure out ways to make writing itself a form of
procrastination. 4. Assign goals for your time – teaching, writing, socializing, watching tv, etc. 5. Cookies and other treats are necessary. So is the gym. 6.
Talking to other students is important and will help you remain
optimistic. Especially, at that stage when the
process
becomes more solitary (think ABD here). 7. Isolation is counterproductive and at its worst paralyzes and fuels insecurities. 8.
Writing is a product and process of collective knowledge. You’re
not as smart as your project on any given day. 9. Writing is re-writing, accept it. 10. Being a scholar is about being a writer.
Job Market
1.
Understand whether the position you are applying for is about teaching
or research, or both and highlight that in
your cover letter 2.
Include all relevant information in your cover letter up front and do
not write more than a page if possible. 3.
Attend as many job talks as you can stand without raising your anxiety
level and participate in job talk prep. 4. Talk to as many people as possible about their experiences and consider their advice. 5. Faculty input from people who have served on search committees is important. 6.
Learn about the department you are applying to in advance of the
application. Have questions for them when you interview, and
remember that they want to know you as a whole person not just as a
scholar.
|